What is it like to negotiate with Russian representatives regarding the war in Ukraine?
This question has generated widespread curiosity in the wake of several latest rounds of peace discussions, which have so far seemed to yield minimal fruit four years after Russia's full-scale military offensive.
Another phase of American-facilitated negotiations is expected to take place in Geneva later this week. Ahead of it, a key participant of the Ukrainian leadership's negotiating team, Sergiy Kyslytsya, who has taken part in the latest military-to-military discussions, has shared his perspective.
According to Kyslytsya, these interactions are professional and mostly free of the type of political and historical posturing seen elsewhere by Moscow.
"The military have a better understanding of the realities in the combat zone," he remarked in a conversation on Monday morning.
"It's another thing if they [the Russians] are capable, or not, of relaying information directly…without cooking or distorting the information," he added.
It is not an easy thing to attempt to halt a war. The nature of the battlefield in eastern Ukraine - where tens of thousands of unmanned aerial vehicles patrol and kill over a huge so-called "contested area" between the opposing forces, while two hundred thousand local civilians still live in the "heavily fortified" cities of the Donbas - renders the practical business of separation highly complex.
"You have to have a precise set of guidelines and procedures," Kyslytsya said, "and a way to confirm and monitor."
The Involvement of External Parties
A great deal of this work, he noted, is complete, thanks in part to the direct participation of US representatives, such as General Alexus Grynkewich and a high-ranking Army official.
Clearly against Kyiv's benefit to criticise representatives of the American administration, but when Kyslytsya compliments the American team for its work, he comes across as genuine.
"We must acknowledge the Americans for their commitment and their perseverance," he says, "since they sit in the meetings continuously. They not only watch…they put inquiries and they listen to our responses."
The negotiator was similarly positive about the roles of the former president's adviser, whom he described as "experienced", and billionaire mediator the special representative, whom he described as "far more astute person than the simplified portrayal you see in the media".
The US, Kyslytsya said, will undertake a critical role in monitoring any future ceasefire, with resources encompassing satellite and other forms of advanced monitoring.
"We need an entity who will play the role of an arbitrator, because if there is a breach there should be a third party that is reliable [and] respected."
Previous and Present Oversight Realities
For eight years before Russia's major invasion in recent years, this monitoring role was handled by the OSCE - a body whose restricted means and lack of punitive powers made it largely unable of averting an intensification.
"That was no small feat [for them] just to have a couple of drones airborne above the area," Kyslytsya commented. "It's kind of the Flintstones era compared to what we have today."
In comparison, recent reports suggest that up to 12,000 drones are active over the urban center of Pokrovsk at any given moment.
A Personal Perspective on Facing the Adversary
Inquired how he managed to negotiate directly from emissaries representing a leader in the Russian government who has shown readiness to expend more than a million of his country's soldiers to subjugate Ukraine, the diplomat, with extensive UN experience, provided his response.
He told that he'd had a long time of practice.
"I saw much worse. I served a five-year term in at the UN, a portion prior to the full-scale invasion. I regularly had to sit in the room with the enemy on a frequent basis."
A particular night is etched in his memory: 23 February 2022.
In the middle of an urgent Security Council session, convened to address the urgent crisis in Ukraine, the ambassador received news that his homeland was under attack.
At the same time, far away to the eastward in Kyiv, initial far-off explosions signaled as Russia's total assault on the nation began.
During scenes of intense tension, the ambassador attempted to get Russia's ambassador, the Russian envoy, to contact his superior, the Russian foreign minister, to seek assurances that Moscow's forces would not cross the border.
"I have stated everything that I am aware of today," the Russian diplomat replied, as recalled by Kyslytsya. "I'm not going to wake Minister Lavrov at this time."
The world were transformed at that instant. Kyslytsya remained at the UN for another three years prior to going back to Kyiv.
The Path Ahead
If the delegations reconvene in Switzerland this week, he will participate, still working through the contours and mechanics of a halt in fighting but anticipating all the while for the crucial element of the jigsaw to fall into place.
"Hostilities could be ended by simply a single order of an individual to his military chief of staff," he said.
"But apparently, the Kremlin dictator [Vladimir Putin] is not up to stopping the war for the time being."